Why a Strong Declaration Can Make or Break Your Family Law Case in Los Angeles

Jun 19

In any California family law case, whether it’s about custody, support, or property division, the written declarations you submit to the court aren’t just paperwork. They’re often the very first things a judge reads about your case. And first impressions matter.

If you're navigating a family law dispute in Los Angeles, understanding the role of a well-crafted declaration can be the difference between a strong position and a rocky start.

What Is a Declaration — and Why Is It So Important?

A declaration is your sworn written statement to the court, laying out the facts of your case from your perspective. Whether you're asking for temporary custody, support, exclusive use of a home, or any other relief, the declaration is how you make your case.

It’s not just evidence, it’s your voice. And in many situations, especially in the early stages of a case, it’s the judge’s first impression of you.

Judges Read Declarations Before They Ever See You

In a city as busy as Los Angeles, family law judges handle hundreds of cases at a time. Before you appear in front of them, they’ve often already reviewed your file, especially your declarations.

What you say, how you say it, and the way it’s presented shapes the judge’s perception of:

Your credibility
Your priorities (what you’re asking for and why)
The overall tone of the conflict
Whether your case seems reasonable and strategic or emotionally reactive and vindictive.

That initial read-through can set the tone for hearings, settlement conferences, or future litigation.

You must hire a Los Angeles family law attorney who knows how to craft declarations in ways that will resonate with the judge. You run the risk of alienating judges with poorly crafted or inconsistent declarations. There’s a common saying, “cases are won and lost on the papers.” We’ve seen this firsthand, many times.

Why Sophistication Matters in a Declaration

A rushed or emotionally charged declaration can undercut even the strongest legal position. Conversely, a calm, credible, and well-structured declaration — backed by strategic planning and documentation — can do more than just support your requests. It can shift the momentum of your case.

For clients with significant assets, complex custody issues, or reputational concerns, a poorly written declaration isn’t just ineffective — it’s risky.

Take, for instance, a case where a mother seeks sole legal and physical custody of two young children due to the father’s substance abuse. She also requests professionally monitored parenting time for the father. The father has a history of driving under the influence, disappearing for long periods, and displaying severe anger. These patterns leave the mother as the sole caretaker, and the inconsistency deeply impacts the children — especially when the father misses family events without explanation. It is also extremely difficult for the mother who feels resentful, betrayed, and angry.

In cases like this, we help our clients document the pattern using testimony, texts, emails, photos, and videos. Then we craft a declaration that is calm and fact focused. In custody cases involving addiction, it’s not about shaming the other parent — it’s about clearly showing that the child’s wellbeing is at risk. That clarity is critical; otherwise, the judge may perceive the concerns as not credible due to exaggeration or emotional charge.

A well-prepared declaration lays out the facts plainly and illustrates the impact on the children’s well-being and household stability.

By taking this approach, we’ve achieved outcomes including sole legal and physical custody, monitored visitation, Soberlink testing, and drug testing. Every case is different, and there are always two sides — but how your story is told can make all the difference.

Declarations Are Not DIY Projects

Because declarations are sworn under penalty of perjury, everything in them must be accurate and supportable. Though declarations are not considered “argument,” they must also be persuasive.

Some people are tempted to prepare declarations themselves or cut corners. But when the stakes are high managing a high-conflict divorce or custody battle, the quality of your written advocacy matters.

This is where experienced family law attorneys come in. A strong legal team ensures your declarations are:

Factually consistent
Strategically focused
Legally compelling
Presented in a tone that resonates with the court.

Not Just What You Say, But What You Don’t

A declaration isn’t a place to vent. Judges look for relevant facts, not personal attacks. A seasoned attorney knows how to address sensitive issues like substance abuse, domestic conflict, or financial misconduct in a way that’s honest, direct, and persuasive — not inflammatory.

Omitting key details or burying the lead can also weaken your credibility. An experienced attorney will help strike the right balance between transparency and strategy.

Declarations and Settlement Strategy

Even in cases where a judge never ultimately rules on a motion, a strong declaration can shape the negotiation dynamic. Opposing counsel reads them. So does the other party. A declaration that lays out a clear, organized, evidence-based, and compelling position can often encourage settlement — or set the stage for a strong hearing.

Final Thoughts

In a complex Los Angeles divorce or custody matter, the declaration is not just paperwork. It’s a foundational element of your case and your reputation with the court.

At our firm, we work with clients to ensure every declaration is a reflection of the strategy, sophistication, and credibility we bring to every matter. Whether you’re preparing for an upcoming hearing or thinking about filing, we’ll help make sure the first thing the judge reads is working in your favor, not against you.

—-

Emily Rubenstein Law PC is a full service divorce and family law firm. We proudly serve Beverly Hills, West Hollywood, West Los Angeles, Santa Monica, Culver City, the South Bay, Glendale, Pasadena, Sherman Oaks, Studio City, Encino and all of Los Angeles County.

Give us a call or check out our website:

(310) 750-0827 | www.emilyrubensteinlaw.com

Brittany Aberle